INDEPENDENT MEDICAL EVALUATION OUTCOME DATA

Richard T. Knoebel, M. D.

7/7/98 THROUGH 7/7/00 (2 YEARS)

INDEPENDENT MEDICAL EVALUATIONS

WORKERS COMPENSATION-------------------------------------- 832 (86%)

PERSONAL INJURY-------------------------------------------------- 141 (14%)

TOTAL 973

Workers Compensation Causation

INDUSTRIAL----------------------------------------------------------- 650 (79%)

NONINDUSTRIAL----------------------------------------------------- 170 (20%)

INDETERMINATE----------------------------------------------------- 12 ( 1%)

TOTAL 832

DEPOSITIONS

WORKERS COMPENSATION--------------------------------- 14 of 832 <2%)

PERSONAL INJURY--------------------------------------------- 12 of 141 8.5%)

COURT APPEARANCES

PERSONAL INJURY -------------------------------------------- 14 of 141 (10%)

WORKERS COMPENSATION -------------------------------- 0 of 832 (0%)

TOTAL -------------------------------------------------------------- 14 of 973 (1%)

DEPOSITIONS AND COURT APPEARANCES

PERSONAL INJURY ------------------------------------------- 26 of 141 (18%)

TOTAL -( Personal Injury and Workers Compensation)---- 40 of 973 ( 4%)